Many people assume IRS penalty cases involve taxpayers who ignored their obligations. In reality, some of the strongest relief requests arise when a major life event collides with complicated tax reporting. For example, a surviving spouse who sells a rental property and files a return late may face penalties and interest on top of the tax itself. This guide is general information and is not based on any particular client.
1. How a rental sale creates a large tax bill
Selling rental property can trigger several layers of tax: long-term capital gain, depreciation recapture taxed as unrecaptured Section 1250 gain, and possibly the Net Investment Income Tax. Together these can produce a much larger tax bill than many sellers expect. Changing from a joint return to filing as a single individual can also raise the tax rate on the same income.
2. The health insurance subsidy surprise
People who buy coverage through the Marketplace often receive advance Premium Tax Credits based on expected income. When a property sale sharply increases income, some or all of those credits may have to be repaid on the tax return. This repayment can add significantly to the bill and often comes as a surprise.
3. How penalties and interest grow
A late return can bring a failure-to-file penalty, which is generally one of the most severe civil penalties for individuals. Unpaid tax can also carry a failure-to-pay penalty that keeps accruing until the balance is addressed, plus interest on both the tax and certain penalties. Over time, the total balance can grow well beyond the original tax.
4. First-Time Abatement
First-Time Abatement is an administrative waiver for taxpayers with a good compliance history. Eligibility generally depends on whether prior years were filed on time and whether certain penalties were previously assessed. Where it applies, it is often the fastest route to removing significant penalties.
5. Reasonable cause
If First-Time Abatement is not available, reasonable cause may be. The IRS looks at whether the taxpayer used ordinary business care and prudence but still could not comply. The death of an immediate family member, serious illness, incapacity, disasters, and lost records are common factors, but the taxpayer must show how the hardship actually caused the late filing or payment. Hardship alone is not enough.
6. Why the timeline matters
After a spouse's death, a survivor may lose access to records, take over finances and tax preparation for the first time, and handle probate, estate administration, and real estate matters. A strong request lays out a clear chronology: what happened, when, how it affected compliance, what steps were taken, and when the obstacle was resolved. The IRS focuses on the gap between the due date and the filing date, so the stronger the timeline, the stronger the request.
If you face IRS penalties after a loss in the family
- Do not assume penalties are permanent; ask whether First-Time Abatement or reasonable cause applies.
- Build a dated timeline of the death, estate and property matters, and your tax filing efforts.
- Keep records such as death certificates, probate filings, closing statements, and correspondence with advisors.
- Check whether Marketplace health subsidies may need to be repaid after a large sale.
- Do not send confidential details or documents through a website contact form.
Get help from someone who has seen it from the inside
William “Bernie” McCarthy is a former IRS agent, Appeals Officer, and IRS attorney. McCarthy Tax Law, P.A., based in Melbourne Beach and representing taxpayers nationwide, can review your penalties and prepare a relief request. Meetings are held via Zoom or by phone. Learn more about our penalty abatement services.
More taxpayer guides
- Collectors Beware: Tax Software May Be Reporting Your Sales Incorrectly
- Does Worker Misclassification Automatically Eliminate IRS Tax Debt?
- IRS Notice About the Sale of Your Home: What It Means
- What Happens in a Criminal Tax Investigation?
- FBAR and Offshore Accounts: What Must You Report?
- What Happens in U.S. Tax Court?
- What Happens in an IRS Audit?
- Can You Settle IRS Tax Debt for Less Than You Owe?
- Got a Letter From the IRS? What It Means and What to Do
- How to Get IRS Penalties Removed
- How IRS Payment Plans Work
This article provides general information, not legal advice for your situation.